I mean, the transgender rep in Ugly Betty is obviously flawed for casting a cisgender actress as a transgender woman, but for the time it was written, I'm honestly shocked it's as nuanced and well-written as it is. And the fact that going into this show I had no idea that this was even going to be a plotline for a main character is insane. The show came out in 2006 and yeah it's the big twist of the first season, but the fact that I was never spoiled for this is crazy especially considering how much time I spend on the designated queer people talk about TV shows website.
The fact of the matter is I really like Alexis Meade, I think her storyline while clumsily handled sometimes is actually really well done and if only it hadn't been 2006 and casting a transgender actress was a beyond unheard of thing I really think Alexis Meade could have been an icon. It's really too bad I've never heard of her before, she really is a revolutionary character being one of the first transgender main characters on a mainstream TV show in the early 2000s and she was nuanced and well-written, she wasn't a villain or a stereotype she was a real person whom I'm sure her inclusion in this show was a lot of people's first introduction to trans people. Ugly Betty actually took the time to explore why Alexis would do the melocramatic soap opera thing of faking her death only to return with a sex change, they treated her story with respect and explored her motivations as if she was a real person rather than using her as a punchline or shock value and I truly was not expecting that.
They didn't have to do that, but they did, this show really took their core theme of "every woman is beautiful in her own way" and said Yes, even trans women and I for one think that's beautiful